System for Evaluating the pH and Buffering Capacity of Moisture Containing Cleansing Articles

ABSTRACT

A system comprising a moisture containing cleansing article and a visual pH indicator changing color at a pH above 4.0. The system can comprise a buffer, having preferably a pKa above 5.5. The system can comprise a set of instructions for evaluating moisture containing cleansing articles. The pH buffer of the system can have a pKa value equal to or greater than the pH of the color change of the visual pH indicator. The pH of color change of the visual pH indicator can be equal to or greater than the pH of the lotion. The system can be used to evaluate the pH of moisture containing cleansing article lotions and to quantify the ability to neutralize alkalinity such as the alkalinity provided by residues of feces and urine over time on the skin of a baby.

CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATION

This application is a continuation of application Ser. No. 11/153,751, filed Jun. 15, 2005, which claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 60/579,867, filed Jun. 15, 2004, both of which are hereby incorporated by reference in their entireties.

FIELD OF THE INVENTION

The invention relates to a system for evaluating the pH and buffering capacity on skin of a moisture containing cleansing article lotion. The system can comprise a moisture containing cleansing article, a pH indicator and a pH buffer.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

Moisture containing cleansing articles have many uses in everyday life: In the personal hygiene area, moisture containing cleansing articles are used to help cleaning the skin of babies, children or adults after bowel movements. In cosmetics moisture containing cleansing articles can be used to clean facial skin or other body parts. For example moisture containing cleansing articles can be used to remove residues of make-up.

Moisture containing cleansing articles usually comprise a substrate and a lotion that helps removing residues from the skin and protects the skin from a too stringent abrasive or irritating effect. The lotion can be water based, oil-based and/or can be an emulsion of water and hydrophobic components.

When moisture containing cleansing articles are put in contact with human skin, the lotion plays a crucial role in the protection of the skin. Mechanical protection from abrasion, hydration of the skin, deposition of a protective layer, are among the most common desired effects.

In personal hygiene and cosmetic uses, skin condition, prior to the use of the moisture containing cleansing article, can be in a deteriorated state: Residues or feces, urine and perspiration, for example, have a pH that increases over time. They unbalance the natural, slightly acid pH of the skin and render it more susceptible to rash, redness and irritation.

Lotions for moisture containing cleansing articles can therefore be also designed to help restoring the natural pH balance of the skin, to a natural pH of about 5.5. To that effect lotion can be characterized by their pH (usually neutral or slightly acidic) and by their buffering capacity. The buffering capacity is an indication of how effective the lotion is in counteracting the increase over time of the pH of the residues of feces or urine (leading to an alkalinity of the skin environment) and to restore a natural skin pH.

It is of interest to evaluate the pH of moisture containing cleansing article lotions. In that regard, pH indicators are of many types: Sensors connected to an electronic system can provide a precise reading of pH. Classical titration by an acid is well known in the art. pH papers or pH stripes are simple indicators that provide a pH reading over a defined pH range. They usually comprise a dried indicator dye applied on a substrate (paper stripe or polymeric stick), that changes its color when immersed into an aqueous solution depending on the pH of the solution and thus provide a pH reading by comparison to a colored reference scale. pH paper sticks and pH measurement of body fluids are, for example, described in WO9838905A1 by James C. Caillouette. The association of feminine pads with a pH indicator is, for example, described in U.S. Pat. No. 5,823,953 by J. M. Richards and A. C. Roskin.

Moreover, it is also of interest to evaluate the buffering potential of various moisture containing cleansing article lotions. For instance some lotions can exhibit a neutral pH but have little effect on restoring the natural pH of the skin because they are ineffective in overcoming the pH increase over time of the residues of feces, urine or perspiration (leading to alkalinity of the skin environment). Some other lotions can exhibit both a neutral pH and a significant buffering potential and thus be much more efficient in restoring a natural skin pH balance. Net, measurement of pH is an indication of the effect of a lotion on skin but not sufficient to determine the efficiency of a lotion.

It is of interest to develop a simple test that would allow for the comparison of moisture containing cleansing article lotions as for their efficiency and ability to restore a natural pH of the skin. It is of interest to measure with this test, the pH of the lotion in a simple and visual way. It is of interest to measure the buffering potential of the moisture containing cleansing article lotions. It is finally of interest to develop a simple, fast, easy to use test to measure both the pH and the buffering potential of moisture containing cleansing article lotions. Such a test would be useful because it would allow users of wipe products to compare the effectiveness of the various products in helping to maintain a desirable skin pH.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

A method is described that comprises using a visual pH indicator and pH buffer to differentiate between moisture containing cleansing articles comprising different lotions. The method may comprise providing the pH indicator, providing the pH buffer, applying the pH indicator and the pH buffer to a surface, wiping the surface with each of the moisture containing cleansing articles, determining a pH response for each of the moisture containing cleansing articles based on a color change of the pH indicator, and comparing the moisture containing cleansing articles based on the pH response. The method may further comprise measuring a lotion pH using the pH indicator and differentiating between wipes having a pH value more acidic than 7.0. At least two of the wipes may have different buffering capacities. The surface may be an absorbing or non-absorbing substrate. The pH indicator and the pH buffer may be printed directly on a leaflet, magazine, box, or printed document. The pH indicator and the pH buffer may be an integral part of the moisture containing cleansing article.

The method may comprise mailing the surface to consumers, or inserting the surface into a magazine. The pH indicator may be selected from the group consisting of phenolphtaleine, tetrabromophenolphtaleine, m-cresolpurpur, bromcresolpurpur, thymolblue, phenylred, bromthymolblue, methyl red, Bromcresol green, Bromcresol purple, chlorphenol red, Bromphenol blue, p-Nitrophenol, Azolitimin, Phenol red, Neutral red, Rosolic acid, Cresol red, alpha-Naphtholphthalein, Tropeolin OOO, alpha-Naphtholbenzein, Thymolphthalein, Nile blue, Alizarin yellow, nitrazin yellow, brilliant yellow, Diazo violet, Tropeolin O, Nitramine, Poirrier's blue, Trinitrobenzoic acid, and mixtures thereof.

A process is described, comprising providing a visual pH indicator, a pH buffer, a colored pH reference and a moisture containing cleansing article comprising a lotion, extracting at least partially some of the lotion from a moisture containing cleansing article, contacting the partially extracted lotion with the pH buffer and the visual pH indicator, and comparing the color of the visual indicator to the colored pH reference. The pH buffer may have a pKa value of at least 5.5. The process may further comprise providing a set of instructions and using the set of instructions for evaluating the moisture containing cleansing article.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

Definitions: The following terms are used interchangeably in the present document.

“Moisture containing cleansing articles”, “wipes”, “wiping articles” are products generally comprising a substrate and a lotion. The substrate can be a nonwoven material comprising synthetic polymer fibers (such as from thermoplastic polymers), include natural fibers such as cellulosic fibers, or comprise a mixture of both. Moisture containing cleansing articles can have personal hygiene uses (such as baby wipes), cosmetic uses (make-up removal wipes, cleansing wipes, etc.) or other more general uses (for other human body parts, for animals or plants, or for delicate objects or surfaces). Examples and illustrations in that document will focus on baby wipes, without limiting the invention to the other uses.

“Lotions”, “softening lotions or compositions”, are a substantially liquid mixture of compounds that impregnate the moisture containing cleansing article. The lotion is in most instances intended to help the removal of residues (such as feces, urine and perspiration), to hydrate the treated surface (e.g., facial or perianal skin), to soften the treated surfaces, or to protect the treated surfaces by leaving a light coating of lotion compounds on the treated surfaces after the treatment. In many instance the lotion are mixtures of hydrophilic compounds, water and oily compounds (such as silicon-based lotions, silicon polyether containing lotions, micro emulsions) The lotions can include emulsifiers to form for example emulsions.

“Visual pH indicators”, “pH stripe”, “pH sticks” are articles or chemicals that change color in response to the pH of their environment (for example when contacted with an aqueous solution). Generally the color change is the result of a change in the structure of a pH sensitive chemical (e.g., an indicator dye). The chemical is bound to a substrate such as a paper or a synthetic substrate, for easy handling.

“pH buffer(s)”, “buffering system”, “buffering salts”, “buffer(s)” or “pH buffering salts” are chemicals that have the ability to buffer the pH change of their environment when put in solution. A buffer is a substance which by its presence in solution increases the amount of acid or alkali that must be added to cause unit change in pH. The salts can be in a solid form for example crystalline form or precipitated powder or can be dissolved in a solution. Buffers for this invention can comprise organic or/and inorganic species or mixture thereof. Examples of relevant buffers comprise: phosphoric acid, and its salts, ammonia and its salts, sulfuric acid and its salts, carboxylic acid and it's salts, carbonic acid and it's salts citric acid and its salts, acetic acid and its salts, tartric acid and its salts, boric acid and its salts, phtalic acid and its salts or organic buffering systems such as TRIS-(hydroxymethyl aminomethane), triethanolamine, 2,4,6 trimethylpyridine, glycin, glycylglycin, diethanolamine, piperazin-1,4-bis(2-ethansulfonicacid), imidazol. Buffers exhibit best buffering effects at a pH around their intrinsic pKa. General information on buffers can be found in chemistry textbooks, in particular “Chemistry (“Chemie”), Dr Hans Rudolf Christen, 1977, Press Diesterweg-Sauerländer, ISBN: 3-7941-0169-1”.

The invention describes a system comprising a visual pH indicator and a moisture containing cleansing article, a process and the use of such a system. One use of the system of the present invention can be to compare the ability of different moisture containing cleansing articles to restore healthy, natural, substantially neutral skin conditions. The system can be used as a demonstration kit in which the consumer can perform the test by using the components provided with the system, and by following instructions provided with the system. The kit can be distributed, mailed to consumers or can be inserted into magazines or publications. The system or the corresponding demonstration kit can be useful to highlight differences between moisture containing cleansing articles (and their lotions) in sale events.

In some embodiments the elements of the system (such as the pH indicator, the moisture containing cleansing article(s)) are juxtaposed, that is provided in close relation to each other for easier use: For example the pH indicator, with or without the pH buffer, can be glued or attached by any means to the pack containing the moisture containing cleansing article(s) or to the moisture containing cleansing article(s) itself. In other embodiments, the elements are packed separately but can be easily unpacked by the person handling the system. In further embodiments the elements of the system are presented in a box, carton, pouch, leaflet, printed document or magazine. Alternatively some elements of the system, such as the visual pH indicator and/or the buffering salts can be integral parts of the presenting support or pack (for example can be printed directly on the leaflets, magazine, box or printed document), or being integral part of the wipe.

The system allows for an easy, convenient evaluation of some key characteristics of moisture containing cleansing article lotion. The pH of the lotion can be easily and quickly revealed by the visual pH indicator, that changes color if the pH of the lotion is about a defined threshold. The threshold is selected to correspond to the pH range close to the one of the skin, namely a pH of 4.0, 5.0, or 5.5. Alternatively the threshold value can be 8.0, 7.0 6.5, 6.0. Visual pH indicators (including those in a form of paper stripe or sticks) that are active over the specified ranges are well known and easily commercially available from many chemical companies, such as Merck Co (Germany).

It has been found that the system of the present invention can comprise pH buffers. When the lotion is put in contact with the buffer, the lotion equilibrates with the buffer in an acid < > base equilibrium. The final pH of the lotion after equilibration (as measured by the visual pH indicator of the system) is therefore the result of the interaction of the lotion with the buffer (the pH indicator is assumed to bring negligible buffering capacity to the system. The buffering capacity of the pH indicator has nevertheless to be counted as part of the total buffering capacity of the buffer in the system). As such the system exhibits an “inertia” in the measurement of the pH of the lotion. That “inertia” is provided by the buffering capacity of the buffer. The buffer (i.e., its buffering capacity) is intended to correspond to the buffering capacity of the residues (of feces, urine, perspiration, make-up—for instance). In that respect, the measurement of the pH of the lotion in presence of the buffer (as illustrated by the present invention), corresponds to the measurement of the pH of the lotion and skin after the wiping action and after the lotion has somewhat interacted with the feces residues. In other words, the system enables the illustration of the pH of the baby skin after the wiping action. As such, the system allows for a unique comparison of the capacity of moisture containing cleansing articles to restore natural skin conditions.

The association of a buffer with the system presented hereby characterizes one of the finding of this invention, as a unique way to measure not only the pH of a lotion but also its buffering capacity.

It has been found that the invention—in some of its embodiments—performs at best when the pH buffer has a pKa value equal or greater than the pH of the color change of the visual pH indicator. Additionally, in some other embodiments, the pH of the color change of the visual pH indicator is equal to or greater than the pH of the lotion.

Many of the residues usually removed by the wiping action often tend to render their environment alkaline over time (for example residues of feces or urine). The buffer can therefore also provide for an alkaline pH in the system. In some embodiments, the pKa of the buffer (when put in solution) is at least 5.5, alternatively at least 7.5, 8.0, 8.5, 9.5, 10, 11, and 12.

In some embodiments, the visual pH indicator and/or the buffer are provided in a solid form (such as crystals, precipitated and/or dried powders). These chemicals can be made in the form of pellets or compacted powders. These chemicals can also be coated or deposited on a substrate such as a paper stripe or a synthetic stick, for easier handling and convenience, either separately or as a mixture. In one embodiment, the visual pH indicator and the buffer have both been deposited or absorbed as solid chemicals at the surface of a stripe of paper or of synthetic polymer. Examples of suitable visual pH indicators are: phenolphtaleine, tetrabromophenolphtaleine, m-cresolpurpur, bromcresolpurpur, thymolblue, phenylred, bromthymolblue, methyl red, thymolblue, Bromcresol green, Bromcresol purple, chlorphenol red, Bromphenol blue, p-Nitrophenol, Azolitmin, Phenol red, Neutral red, Rosolic acid, Cresol red, alpha-Naphtholphthalein, Tropeolin OOO, Thymol blue, Phenolphthalein, alpha-Naphtholbenzein, Thymolphthalein, Nile blue, Alizarin yellow, nitrazin yellow, brilliant yellow, Salicyl yellow, Diazo violet, Tropeolin O, Nitramine, Poirrier's blue, Trinitrobenzoic acid, or mixtures thereof.

Alternatively the visual pH indicator and/or the buffer are provided in a liquid form, either as separately or as a mixture.

In other alternatives, the pH indicators and/or the pH buffer are first made as liquid solution(s), absorbed or deposited on a substrate (such as a stripe of absorbing or not absorbing substrates, for example as a stripe of paper), and then dried. The buffer and/or the pH visual indicator can be released from the substrate by dissolving the dried chemicals in a solution (for example water). The solution is then used as part of the system of the present invention. Alternatively the dried chemicals are dissolved directly in the wipe lotion.

A buffer solution comprises at least 2 species of the buffer in solution: A first specie is capable of reacting with OH⁻ and the second specie is capable of reacting with H₃O⁺. The two species must not react with each other. Many buffers are prepared by combining a weak acid and its conjugate (acetic acid and sodium acetate) or a weak base and its conjugate (ammonia and ammonium chloride). In general, the pH range in which a buffer solution is effective is +/− one pH unit on either side of the pKa. The Henderson-Hasselbalch provides the information needed to prepare a buffer.

${pH} = {{pKa} + {\log \frac{\left\lbrack {{conjugate}\mspace{11mu} {base}} \right\rbrack}{\left\lbrack {{weak}\; {acid}} \right\rbrack}}}$

There is a limit to the amount of acid or base that can be added to a buffer solution before one of the components is used up. This limit is called the buffer capacity and is defined as the moles of acid or base necessary to change the pH of one liter of solution by one unit.

${{Buffer}\mspace{14mu} {Capacity}} = \frac{\left( {{number}\mspace{14mu} {of}\mspace{14mu} {moles}\mspace{14mu} {of}\mspace{14mu} {OH}^{-}\mspace{14mu} {or}\mspace{14mu} H_{3}O^{+}\mspace{11mu} {added}} \right)}{\left( {{pH}\mspace{14mu} {change}} \right)\left( {{volume}\mspace{14mu} {of}\mspace{14mu} {buffer}\mspace{14mu} {in}\mspace{14mu} L} \right)}$

The pH buffer of the invention can be an organic or inorganic buffer, or a mixture thereof and can include one of more species alone or in combinations, from the list: phosphoric Acid, and its salts, ammonia and its salts, sulfuric Acid and its salts, carboxylic acid and it's salts, citric acid and its salts, acetic acid and its salts, tartric acid and its salts, boric acid and its salts, phtalic acid and its salts, carbonic acid and it's salts, bicarbonate salts, TRIS-(hydroxymethyl aminomethane) triethanolamine, 2,4,6 trimethylpyridine, glycin, glycylglycin, diethanolamine, piperazin-1,4-bis(2-ethansulfonicacid), imidazol.

The pH buffer of the present invention can have a buffering capacity of adding at least 0.0001 mol/l of an acid or base without changing the pH value by 1 pH unit or more. Alternatively, the buffering capacity can be 0.001, 0.01, 0.1, 1 or 10 mol/1.

In some embodiments, user instructions are provided as part of the system of the present invention. Typically the instructions are written instructions, but can also be provided as audio, video, visual graphics or combination thereof. The instructions can provide information to the user on the importance of the skin health, on the alteration of skin induced over time by residues, on the benefits of lotions for wipes and/or the benefits of a natural pH balance. The instructions can indicate to the user how to use the components of the system of the invention to evaluate wipes. For example, the instructions can describe the steps of contacting a wipe with a visual pH indicator in presence of a buffer. The instructions can describe that 1, 2, 3, 5, 7, 9, 10 or more prolonged contacts of about 0.5 second are needed to best visualize the results. Alternatively or additionally, the instructions can describe the dissolution of a solid form of pH buffer and pH indicator absorbed on a substrate(s) into water (or into an aqueous solution). Alternatively or additionally, the instructions can include the use of the resulting solution for contacting the wipe and evaluating their pH and/or buffering capacity. The instructions can describe the steps of reading the pH color of the visual pH indicator and/or comparing the color with a reference. The reference can be provided in a written form, as graphics, as audio, as video, as icons, as colors or any combination thereof, or in any other suitable means. The instructions can include information to evaluate moisture containing cleansing articles as for the pH of the wipe lotion, the pH of the skin after use and/or buffering capacity of the wipe lotion.

Example: In one embodiment of the present invention the pH indicator is “Brilliant Yellow” available from Merck (Germany), the pH buffer is a TRIS-(hydroxymethyl aminomethane). The pH indicator and pH buffer have been both coated onto a substrate (a stripe of synthetic material of 5 cm long×5 mm wide). The moisture containing cleansing articles are Pampers® Baby Wipes Sensitive, as sold in Germany at the filing date of the present application. Other wipes are been tested, including Johnson & Johnson ExtraCare Aloe & Willow herb, Nivea Baby Sensitive, Huggies Cotton Touch Sensitive/Ziplock, and Auchan Prestige Sensitive as illustrated in table 1.

The measurement of the pH of the lotion is made according to any method known in the art (for example, extraction and collection of the lotion from the wipe by application of a load on the stack of wipes, collection of the lotion and pH measurement of the collected lotion via an electronic pH-meter.

The protocol for the testing reported in table 1 is as follows: The wipe is removed from its packaging and contacted 5 times (each for about 0.5 to 1 second) under light hand pressure to the substrate (stripe) coated with the pH indicator and the buffer (in this case a TRIS buffer). The change of color of the stripe is evaluated by comparison to a reference colored chart. One observes that Pampers® Baby Wipes Sensitive induces a change of color of the pH visual indicator from orange/red to yellow. The other wipes tested don't induce a color change to yellow. The change of color to yellow indicates a final pH of below 7.0. The results is interpreted as a better ability of the wipes to restore a neutral pH on the skin, even in presence of the “reservoir” of alkalinity provided in-situ by the feces residues and in the experiment by the pH buffer of the system of the invention.

TABLE 1 J&J ExtraCare Huggies Cotton Pampers Sensitive Aloe & Nivea Baby Touch Sensitive/ Auchan Prestige Wipe product wipes Willowherb Sensitive Ziplock Sensitive Labeled Aqua, Dimethicone, Aqua, Paraffinum Aqua, PEG-40 Aqua, Potassium Aqua, Paraffinum ingredients Propylene Glycol, Aloe Liquidum, Hydrogenated Laureth liquidium, Barbadensis, Bisabolol, Ceteareth-12, Castor Oil, Phosphate, Glycerin, Chamomilla Recutita, Phenoxyethanol, Glycerin, Glycerin, Caprylyl/Capryl, Sodium Acrylates, Glyceryl Stearate, Phenoxyethanol, Polysorbate 20, Glucoside, Vinyl Isodecanoate Glyceryl Oleate, Methylparaben, Tetrasodium Butylene Glycol, Crosspolymer, Sorbitan Aloe Barbadensis Potassium Sorbate, EDTA, DMDM Sodium Oleate, Caprylic/Capric Leaf Juice, Sodium Citrate, Hydantoin, Polyacrylate & Triglyceride, Sodium Epilobium Panthenol, Citric Methylparaben, Ethylhexylstearate Phosphate, Sodium Angustifolium Acid, Malic acid & Trideceth 6, Bonzoate, Extract, Avena Propylparaben Prunus Amygdalus Methylparaben, Sativa, Propylene (Sweet Almond) Ethylparaben, Glycol, Coco- Oil, Propylene Propylparaben, Glucoside, Glycol & Mel Disodium Ceteareth-20, Extract, EDTA, Polysorbate 20 Cetearyl Alcohol, Methylparaben, Cetyl Palmitate, Allantoin, 2- Tetrasodium EDTA, Bromo-2- Cetylpyridinium Nitropropane-1.3 Chloride, Citric Diol, Acid, Lactic Acid, Butylparaben, Sodium Benzoate, Ethylparaben, Potassium Sorbate, Propylparaben. PEG-4 Laurate, Iodopropynyl Butylcarbamate, Parfum Lotion pH 5.4 5.4 5.3 5.6 6.1 (measured) Buffering 13.0 ml 1.9 ml 4.6 ml 6.1 7.0 ml capacity of the lotion (measured as the volume of NaOH added to reach a final pH of 7.0 (titration curve) Color of the Yellow red dark-orange light-orange Red visual pH indicator after contacting the wipe of the pH color indicator in presence of a pH buffer (Tris)

All documents cited in the Detailed Description of the Invention are, in relevant part, incorporated herein by reference; the citation of any document is not to be construed as an admission that it is prior art with respect to the present invention.

While particular embodiments of the present invention have been illustrated and described, it would be obvious to those skilled in the art that various other changes and modifications can be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention. It is therefore intended to cover in the appended claims all such changes and modifications that are within the scope of this invention. 

1. A method of using a visual pH indicator and pH buffer to differentiate between moisture containing cleansing articles comprising different lotions, the method comprising: a) providing the pH indicator; b) providing the pH buffer; c) applying the pH indicator and the pH buffer to a surface; d) wiping the surface with each of the moisture containing cleansing articles; e) determining a pH response for each of the moisture containing cleansing articles based on a color change of the pH indicator; and f) comparing the moisture containing cleansing articles based on the pH response.
 2. The method of claim 1, the method further comprising measuring a lotion pH using the pH indicator and differentiating between wipes having a pH value more acidic than 7.0, wherein at least two of the wipes have different buffering capacities.
 3. The method of claim 1, wherein the surface is an absorbing or non-absorbing substrate.
 4. The method of claim 3, wherein the pH indicator and the pH buffer are printed directly on a leaflet, magazine, box, or printed document.
 5. The method of claim 3, wherein the visual pH indicator and the pH buffer are an integral part of the moisture containing cleansing article.
 6. The method of claim 1, further comprising mailing the surface to consumers.
 7. The method of claim 1, further comprising inserting the surface into a magazine.
 8. The method of claim 1, wherein the pH indicator is selected from the group consisting of phenolphtaleine, tetrabromophenolphtaleine, m-cresolpurpur, bromcresolpurpur, thymolblue, phenylred, bromthymolblue, methyl red, Bromcresol green, Bromcresol purple, chlorphenol red, Bromphenol blue, p-Nitrophenol, Azolitmin, Phenol red, Neutral red, Rosolic acid, Cresol red, alpha-Naphtholphthalein, Tropeolin OOO, alpha-Naphtholbenzein, Thymolphthalein, Nile blue, Alizarin yellow, nitrazin yellow, brilliant yellow, Diazo violet, Tropeolin O, Nitramine, Poirrier's blue, Trinitrobenzoic acid, and mixtures thereof.
 9. The method of claim 8, wherein the pH indicator is selected from the group consisting of phenolphtaleine, tetrabromophenolphtaleine, m-cresolpurpur, bromcresolpurpur, thymolblue, bromthymolblue, Bromcresol green, Bromcresol purple, Bromphenol blue, p-Nitrophenol, alpha-Naphtholphthalein, Thymolphthalein, nitrazin yellow, diazo violet, Poirrier's blue, and mixtures thereof.
 10. The method of claim 9, wherein the pH indicator is selected from the group consisting of tetrabromophenolphtaleine, thymolblue, bromthymolblue, Bromcresol green, Bromphenol blue, p-Nitrophenol, nitrazin yellow, diazo violet, and mixtures thereof.
 11. The process comprising: providing a visual pH indicator, a pH buffer, a colored pH reference and a moisture containing cleansing article comprising a lotion; extracting, at least partially, some of the lotion from a moisture containing cleansing article; contacting the partially extracted lotion with the pH buffer and the visual pH indicator; and comparing the color of the visual pH indicator to the colored pH reference.
 12. The process of claim 11 wherein the pH buffer has a pKa value of at least 5.5.
 13. The process of claim 11 further comprising providing a set of instructions and using the set of instructions for evaluating the moisture containing cleansing article. 